This is the bomb dot com. Love your comics, love your geeky references, love your recipes! Well, technically I haven’t tried to make this yet, but it looks like it tastes like heaven and rainbows. Keep being awesome
Tried an improvised version of this the other night, increasing the amount of frozen bananas and PB to make up for the lack of ice cream (barely a scoop), and added butterscotch chips (due to having no reeses pieces) It turned out pretty good, but after going to the store last night, I’m ready to try the real thing.
As soon as the bananas ripen up a bit. Darn Winco had nothing but green bananas…
@Gem, maybe this will work? I’m thinking substituting PB with Nutella and the Reeses Pieces with M&Ms. I’m allergic to peanuts as well. Unfortunately I’m not close to anywhere with a kitchen, so I’m going to have to wait for a few months till I get home to give it a shot.
This website is awesome, I can’t wait to see more to come! Keep it up. Looking forward to the cook book! (You know you want to!)
I intentionally made a trip out to the store to get the stuff just for this recipe. (Ok, it got me away from the PITA wife too). I will be making it as soon as my green ass bananas turn yellow. In the mean time, I will check here often. You are my new homepage. (Not really but I figure exaggerating only makes it more awesome).
Keep up the legen…wait for it…dary work and make an effing book, I will buy.
I LITERALLY just made this, and am eating it now its super delicious, but next time I’m going to only use 2 bananas and smaller scoops of ice cream because the batch I just made looks like it’ll last me all week. also, because i ended up with sooo much bananarama, it took longer to freeze properly
keep up the awesome work :3 your recipes are awesome, as well as entertaining to read!
I am making this first thing tomorrow! I could make it today…but then I’d have to go to the store…and it’s raining and I’m lazy…so TOMORROW. Anyway! I stumbled upon this site and I LOVE all your recipes. It’s cool to see a cooking site that is real and honest and not so serious. When you put out your book, I’m totally buying it!
I made some of this about a month ago and it was glorious. Peanut butter is one of my favorite flavors and bananas are my favorite fruit. I’m gonna make this again and I think I might add some nutella for some hazlenutty taste!
Mmmm… Sounds delish. Wish I wasn’t allergic to the stupid artificial colors in the Reese’s Pieces (one of my all-time favorites until I discovered the allergy. May try making it with the natural dyed M&M knock-offs Whole Foods sells.